Just before leaving Oxford Laura has a discussion with a friend who claims that Americans often don’t understand the true meaning of. “Shakespeare in the Bush” by Laura Bohannan can be used as an introduction to the concept of culture, moral universals, human nature, and anthropology. Laura Bohannan’s article in Natural History, Shakespeare in the Bush introduces anthropology to a broad audience through a retelling of Hamlet.
|Published (Last):||25 November 2012|
|PDF File Size:||9.77 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||12.5 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The argument remained a stalemate as she was preparing to travel to Africa. Her friend gave her a copy of Hamlet as a parting gift with hopes that perhaps she would find the true interpretation. On her trip to Africa the author finds out that custom, translations, and culture play a larger role in the interpretation of Shakespeare and that his meanings were not as universal as she previously thought. During her stay with the Tiv in Africa, Bohannan gets a chance to relay the story of Hamlet to the tribe.
Right away the elder questioned this.
Topic 4: Summary of “Shakespeare in the bush” by Laura Bohannan | Prinsorkide’s Blog
The concept of someone having a ghost or living after they die was very foreign to them. They were convinced that the author had gotten the story wrong because the only explanation for a spirit could be that it gohannan an omen sent by a witch.
Horatio was also viewed as a fool for not bringing such an important matter before a person with proper knowledge of such omens. It is obvious that their customs and traditions were already biasing their interpretation of the story.
In Tiv society it is only natural for the brother of the chief to become chief in the shaksspeare of ahakespeare brothers death. A wife of one of the elders overheard this part of the story and explained that a quick remarriage is ideal. It was obvious to the Tiv woman that the mother had done this in the best interests of the family so Hamlet had no reason to feel negatively about it.
The author tried in vain to explain why these things would make Hamlet miserable. Western society would view this remarriage as a form of incest and would not be socially acceptable.
Also a mourning period would be expected before a widow could be remarried and this was not done. In the elders minds these were normal events and which should not motivate anyone to be depressed.
The Tiv elders had many explanations for the behavior of Hamlet, which held the authors interest.
Analysis of the story “Shakespeare in the bush” Essay
They all agreed that Hamlet was being bewitched and this was the cause of his strange behavior. They clarified that only a male member of ones family had the power to bewitch people therefore it was clearly king Claudius who was behind this.
The Tiv also had an explanation for he supernatural events that occurred. Although these answers were not the same the author viewed she found them fascinating and she modeled the remaining parts of the story around them.
Bohannon was learning that the Tiv culture and belief systems did not allow the storyline to progress in the same way as Shakespeare wrote it. After hearing of the death of Ophelia from the author, the Tiv elder wished to know whom her male relatives were in order to find who was responsible.
He proceeded to tell how Laertes was scheming to get money to pay off his debts. According to the elder, Laertes had bewitched his sister in order to sell her body to the witches.
The elder then concluded that Hamlet had jumped in after him to shakesleare Laertes from snatching the body. He continued to say ahakespeare the son of a chief would not want to see another man to become rich and powerful. He said Laertes would be angry with this and try to kill Hamlet. Bohannan had to agree with this although it may not have been exact; Laertes did wish to kill Hamlet. In his own eyes, the elder understood the meaning of the story correctly even though thw thoughts did not match with the authors.
After the stories conclusion the elder added his thoughts about the tales finish. The poison beer that killed Hamlets mother was obviously meant for the winner of the fight.
According to him if Laertes won the duel, the great chief would have given him the poison. This way no one would no that the king arranged Hamlets death. In addition the elder claimed that the chief would have done this also for fear of Laertes witchcraft.
Someone who kills his own sister with witchcraft is potentially very dangerous. Very pleased that he had correctly interpreted the story, the elder told Bohannan that she should tell them more stories from her country. The elders would then instruct her about the true meaning of the stories so that she could return home unlighted by their wisdom. The Tiv felt that the author was the one. The difference in culture had a large impact on the interpretation of Hamlet.
The argument Laura Bohannan presents is flawed. The Tiv had very different rationalizations for the plot progression and the character motives. The author did not take seriously enough the enormous impact the Tivs different customs and traditions would have on their analysis of Hamlet. Through out this story you can see that human nature does plays no part in the Tivs interpretations of Hamlet. The author learns that culture is the main reason for these differences of opinion.
Accessed December 31, Leave your email and we will send you an example after 24 hours If you contact us after hours, we’ll get back to you in 24 hours or less. Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? How about receiving a customized one? Click to learn more https: Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website! How to cite this page Choose cite format: How about make it original? Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website.
If you need this or any other sample, we can send it to you via email. We’ll occasionally send you account related and promo emails. Sorry, but downloading is forbidden on this website. Hi, I am Sara from Studymoose Hi there, would you like to get such a paper? Your Answer is very helpful for Us Thank you a lot!